Yellow Foot Prints Forums  

Go Back   Yellow Foot Prints Forums > Open Channel

Open Channel [Main Page]
Communicate with your Brothers/sister Marines.

Thread Tools Rate Thread Display Modes
Old 11-26-2014, 02:40 PM
MARINE42's Avatar
MARINE42 MARINE42 is offline
Registered User
Join Date: Oct 2006
Location: wi
Posts: 1,183
Amateur historians dispute Corps' record of iconic WWII photo

Amateur historians dispute Corps' record of iconic WWII photo

Two history buffs made waves this week for challenging the official story behind the iconic photograph of the raising of an American flag atop Mount Suribachi, but Marine

The famous image captured by Associated Press photographer Joe Rosenthal on Iwo Jima quickly became an enduring symbol of the Corps, World War II and spirit of the American troops. The men who lifted the flag between bouts of desperate fighting became national heroes, several posthumously, and later the subjects of books and films.

But 39-year-old amateur historian and Marine Corps enthusiast Eric Krelle believes not all the men credited with raising the flag participated. John Bradley, a navy corpsman most believe was the second person from the right in the famous photo, was not actually in the picture, Krelle said.

Krelle, who runs a website dedicated to the history of 5th Marine Division, began looking more closely at the photographs taken on Feb. 23, 1945, after fellow enthusiast Stephen Foley questioned the identities of two of the men in the image.

As recounted in a recent piece in the Omaha World-Herald, Foley noticed discrepancies about the man in the photograph thought to be Bradley. In others taken around that time, the corpsman wears cuffed pants. The man in Rosenthal's image does not.

The man also dons what appears to be a soft cap beneath his helmet. Other photographs of Bradley show him without it. The man also wore a cartridge belt, complete with ammo pouches and a pair of wire cutters, as opposed to the gear typically carried by a corpsman, they said.

The two would-be sleuths believe the man actually is Pfc. Franklin Sousley. But Sousley already was thought to be in the photograph, just to the left of Bradley.

Who, then, is the man mistakenly — in Krelle's view — thought to be Sousley?

Krelle contends it is Pfc. Harold H. Schultz, who died in 1995, according to Hansen's research. His proof is what might be a loose strap dangling from the Marine's helmet as he steps away from the flag. The moment is captured in footage shot of the flag raising.

A photograph of Schultz taken that day shows him with what Krelle considers the smoking gun: the dangling strap. But that means Bradley, who helped raise an earlier flag on the mountain and later used his fame to raise war bonds, was not in the photograph. It would also mean the Marine Corps' official account of the day is wrong.

The response has been a "mixed bag," Krelle said.

"To me, it's the heart of who Americans define themselves as and for 70 years now these six guys have been looked up to as the heroes of Iwo Jima," he said. "Everybody on Iwo Jima was a hero, but these six individuals, in particular, have been called out. Messing with that tends to rile a lot of people up."

Marine officials, however, are sticking to the Corps' account. Bradley raised the flag alongside: Sgt. Michael Strank; Cpl. Harlan H. Block; Pfc. Rene Gagnon; Pfc. Ira Hayes; and Pfc. Sousley.

"We stand by the Marine Corps' official history," said retired Col. Peter Ferraro, chief of the reference branch of the Marine Corps History Division. "If he disputes it, it's fine — I'm not going to argue with it. We stand by our official history."

Others have scrutinized the photograph, disputing aspects of it over the years, Ferraro added.

The first discrepancy in the story is one of the most famous. Asked to identify his compatriots in the photograph, Gagnon initially counted Sgt. Henry O. Hansen among them. Hansen, killed not long after, participated in the first flag raising, but not the second and more famous effort. An investigation later concluded it was Block, not Hansen, in the photograph.

"This happens; unfortunately, questions arise of this nature often," Ferraro said. "This is not the first time."

Though attempts to reach James Bradley, son of John Bradley and co-author of "Flags of our Fathers," were unsuccessful, he told the Omaha World-Herald that the word of the men there that day was enough for him. If Krelle was right, why did the survivors remain silent, he asked.

Walt Ford, a retired Marine colonel and former associate publisher and editor of Leatherneck Magazine, also questioned Krelle and Foley's theory. He cited multiple investigations over the years, as well as accounts from eyewitnesses.

"This subject, the Mount Suribachi flag raisings, has been and remains the subject of amateur historians and claims by wannabes," Ford said. "That is understandable as that action and the flag raising image itself are hallmarks of American persistence in the pursuit of right. I remain firmly in the camp of the Marine Corps' position."

Krelle, who said he holds great respect for John Bradley and all of the other men who fought at Iwo Jima, hopes historians and Corps officials eventually recognize and accept what he considers the hard evidence buttressing his conclusions.

"I've got three children; someday, when they actually care about this, when they're researching Iwo Jima they will see that these are, truthfully, the six people who raised the flag, not just who the Marine Corps says raised the flag," he said.

Admiration of the Nation We’re the finest ever seen And we glory in the title Of United States Marines.
Reply With Quote

Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests)
Thread Tools
Display Modes Rate This Thread
Rate This Thread:

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is On

Forum Jump

All times are GMT -7. The time now is 12:07 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2020, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright & Copy 2006-2019, Yellow Foot Prints, All Rights Reserved